Blair threw her backpack down in the mudroom hard enough that her water bottle rolled out and clattered against the baseboard, and I was still holding my car keys when she said it.
“Why does Ivy always get picked for everything?”
“What are you talking about?”
“The doughnut thing. You took her to get doughnuts after her dentist appointment and you never do that for me.”
I genuinely did not know what she meant for a second, and then I remembered — Ivy had a cavity filled that morning, cried a little in the chair according to the hygienist, and I’d swung by the bakery on the way home because she looked pale and sad and I thought a doughnut might help. It had felt like such a small, forgettable thing. I hadn’t even mentioned it to Blair, mostly because it hadn’t occurred to me that it was information she’d want.
“Blair, she had a cavity filled. That’s not really the same as—”
“You always do stuff like that for her. Last week you let her stay up to watch the end of the movie and you sent me to bed.”
“That movie wasn’t appropriate for your age, that’s a different—”
“And at the game you said her throw was ‘amazing’ and you didn’t say anything like that to me the whole game.”
I stood there in the mudroom actually trying to remember the softball game in question, and I did remember saying something to Ivy about a throw she’d made from third to first, a genuinely nice piece of fielding, the kind of thing you comment on because it’s true and it’s right there in front of you. I could not, off the top of my head, remember saying anything comparable to Blair, and the longer I stood there failing to remember it, the more uncomfortable I got, because normally in an argument like this I’ve got a ready answer, some version of that’s not how it is, sweetheart, and this time I just didn’t have one loaded.
“I don’t play favorites, Blair. I love you both the same.”
“I didn’t say you loved her more. I said she always gets picked.”
That distinction, delivered by a ten-year-old standing in a mudroom in her softball cleats, was sharper than I expected, and it needled at something I didn’t love examining too closely. Loving them the same had always felt like the whole ballgame to me, the thing I was sure I had covered. Whether I noticed them the same, complimented them the same, chose them the same for small random moments throughout an ordinary week — that was a different ledger entirely, one I hadn’t actually been keeping.
“Okay,” I said. “Let me think about that. I don’t think I’m doing it on purpose, if I am doing it.”
“Whatever,” she said, which is Blair’s current all-purpose word for I don’t believe you but I don’t want to keep fighting about it right now, and she went upstairs without her water bottle, which I ended up carrying up myself twenty minutes later, mostly as an excuse to go check on her.
She was lying on her bed reading when I knocked, didn’t look up right away. “I brought your water bottle.”
“Thanks.”
“You want to talk more about the doughnut thing?”
“Not really.” She turned a page, very deliberately not looking at me, and I decided not to push it, mostly because I didn’t yet have anything useful to say, and I didn’t want to make a bad apology just to feel like I’d done something.
At dinner that night I tried asking Ivy about it too, carefully, not wanting to make her feel accused of anything she hadn’t actually done. “Do you ever notice me doing more stuff with Blair, or more stuff with you?” Ivy looked at me like I’d asked her to explain calculus. “I don’t know. I guess you come to all my games.” It wasn’t an accusation from her, just a fact, stated the way kids state facts, no weight attached, and somehow that offhandedness made the whole situation feel even more lopsided than if she’d said something pointed.
I brought it up with my husband, Darnell, that night after the kids were in bed, half defensive, half genuinely rattled.
“Do you think I favor Ivy?”
He took a second longer to answer than I wanted him to. “I don’t think you favor her. I think Ivy’s just… easier to compliment in the moment? Like, she does a thing, it’s visible, you say something nice about it. Blair’s stuff is quieter. Harder to catch.”
“What do you mean quieter?”
“Like, Ivy makes a good throw at a game everyone’s watching. Blair reads for forty-five minutes without being asked, alone in her room, and nobody’s standing there to see it and say good job.”
I didn’t love that answer because it made a kind of obvious sense I should have landed on myself. Ivy’s whole personality operates in public — she’s loud at games, she performs for an audience, good or bad, and that generates a steady stream of moments where praising her is easy and immediate. Blair does almost everything the opposite way. She reads alone. She draws alone, elaborate comic books she doesn’t show anyone until they’re finished, sometimes not even then. She’s not a kid who hands you an obvious moment to react to; you have to actually go looking for what she’s doing, and if I’m honest, most days I don’t go looking, I just respond to whatever’s loudest in front of me, which in this house is usually Ivy.
I started paying closer attention after that, which sounds like a bigger project than it actually was — it mostly meant I started asking Blair more questions at dinner instead of just letting Ivy fill the silence, and I made a point of going up to her room one evening and asking to see whatever comic she was working on, which she was weirdly shy about at first, like she wasn’t used to being asked.
“It’s not done,” she said, holding the notebook against her chest.
“I don’t need it done. I just want to see what you’re working on.”
She showed me, eventually, a multi-page thing about a girl detective who solves crimes at her own school, genuinely funny in a couple of places, and I told her so, specifically, the actual joke I liked, not just “this is great, honey,” and she looked pleased in a way that made me a little sad about how long it had apparently been since I’d done that.
I don’t think the doughnut thing or the softball comment were some deep injustice that scarred her. I think it was smaller and more ordinary than that — she’d noticed a pattern, the pattern was basically real even if it wasn’t intentional, and she didn’t have the words to explain the whole shape of it, so she grabbed the sharpest example she had and used it. The doughnuts weren’t really the thing. The thing was a running tally she’d apparently been keeping in her head for a while, probably longer than I’d like to know, about who gets noticed around here and who has to ask for it.
A few weeks later I took Blair to get doughnuts too, for no occasion at all, just because, and she looked at me a little suspiciously in the car, like she was waiting for the catch.
“What’s this for?”
“Nothing. Just thought we’d get doughnuts.”
“Is Ivy getting one too?”
“Not right now. This one’s yours.”
She didn’t say much else about it, just ate her doughnut and looked out the window, but she seemed lighter somehow for the rest of the afternoon, and I noticed I felt a little lighter too, like I’d quietly corrected something without either of us having to make a whole production out of it.
I still catch myself complimenting Ivy’s loud, visible stuff faster than I catch Blair’s quiet stuff, probably always will, some, because that’s just how our attention works. But I try to go looking now, on purpose, for the kind of thing Blair does that nobody’s standing around clapping for.
Darnell’s started doing it too, in his own way — he asked Blair last week if he could read the finished comic out loud at dinner, doing voices for all the characters, which embarrassed her and delighted her in roughly equal measure, judging by how many times she asked him to do the villain’s voice again. Ivy sat through the whole reading without complaint, which I noticed and appreciated more than I said out loud, and even laughed in the right places, which I decided to take as a good sign rather than reading anything extra into it.
Is there a kid in your house getting less of your attention simply because they’re quieter about asking for it — and would you even notice if they weren’t telling you?