Behind the Closed Door

Picked Last, Again

November 15, 2026 · By Jenny Wilson, Founder & Creator of the Wonder Family Framework

Sam dropped his backpack by the door the way he always does, except this time he also dropped his whole body down right next to it, sitting on the floor in the entryway still wearing his shoes, which is not a thing he normally does.

“Hey, buddy. Good day?”

“Fine.” He didn’t get up.

I’d learned by then, after eight years of this kid, that “fine” delivered from the floor of the entryway was never actually fine, so I sat down next to him, which made my knees unhappy in a way they didn’t used to be, and waited.

“We did kickball,” he finally said. “At recess.”

“Yeah? How’d that go?”

“I got picked last. Again.” He said “again” like it was a whole separate word with its own weight to it. “Marcus and Caleb are captains every time and they always pick each other’s friends first and I’m always like, the last one, and then whoever has to take me acts like it’s the worst thing that happened to them that day.”

“That’s not – I’m sure it’s not that bad.”

“You weren’t there.”

Fair point. I didn’t have a great comeback for that, so I just sat with him a minute, both of us still in our shoes on the entryway floor, which my wife would have had something to say about if she’d walked in.

Here’s the thing about me and this particular problem: I was picked last plenty of times myself, growing up, and I have spent a disproportionate amount of time since becoming a parent trying to make sure Sam never has to feel that specific flavor of bad. I remember exactly where I was standing in my own elementary school gym the last time it happened to me, which tells you something about how long that kind of thing hangs around. Which meant my brain went immediately into fix-it mode, the way it always does, skipping right past just sitting with the feeling and landing hard on solutions.

“You know what,” I said, “this weekend, you and me, backyard, I’ll teach you to kick that ball so hard nobody’s gonna want to leave you for last again. We’ll work on it. I used to be pretty good at kickball, believe it or not.” I was already picturing it, honestly, the two of us out there with the good kickball from the garage, me lobbing easy ones, him connecting solid, some montage version of fatherhood I’d apparently absorbed from somewhere without noticing.

“I don’t want to practice kickball.” He said it with more force than the sentence seemed to need, like he’d been waiting for an opening to say it the whole time I’d been talking about backyard drills.

“It’ll help, though. If you’re actually good at it, Marcus and Caleb are gonna want you on their team first, that’s just how it works.”

“I don’t care about being good at kickball.” He said it louder than he needed to, almost annoyed with me, which caught me off guard. “I don’t even like kickball that much.”

“Okay. Then what’s the actual problem, is it the game or is it the picking part?”

He picked at a loose thread on his shoelace for a second before answering. “It’s that Marcus used to pick me. Like, before this year. We used to be on the same team every time, we had this whole thing where we’d do a handshake before the game started. And now he picks Caleb first every single time and doesn’t even look at me, and I don’t know why, we didn’t even have a fight or anything.”

And there it was, the actual thing, which had nothing to do with kickball skills at all and everything to do with a friendship that had apparently quietly shifted without anybody declaring it out loud, the way those things do at eight just as much as they do at any other age.

“Did something happen between you two? A fight, an argument, anything?”

“No. I don’t think so. He just started sitting with Caleb at lunch too, like, this whole year. I thought maybe he was mad at me but when I asked him he just said ‘I’m not mad, why would I be mad,’ and then he just went back to talking to Caleb.”

“Did you ever ask him why he stopped picking you for teams?”

“No. What would I even say. ‘Why don’t you pick me anymore.’ That’s so embarrassing, Dad, I would never say that out loud.” He pulled his knees up to his chest. “I just started standing kind of in the back during picks so it’s not as obvious that I’m watching to see who gets picked before me.”

That detail got me more than almost anything else he’d said, the idea of him quietly repositioning himself at the back of a line of eight-year-olds just to manage his own humiliation a little better, all on his own, without ever mentioning it to anyone until right now.

I thought about offering to call the teacher, see if she could do something about the team-picking system, maybe suggest she assign teams herself instead of letting two third-graders run a popularity contest at recess every day. I actually had my phone halfway out of my pocket to type a note to myself about it, already composing the email in my head, something reasonable-sounding about “structured team selection” that would have made me feel better and almost certainly made things worse for him.

“Do you want me to say something to your teacher? Maybe she could-“

“No. Dad, no. Please don’t.” Same reaction I probably should have expected. “That would make it so much worse. Everyone would know you called.”

“Okay. I won’t do that.” I put the phone back. “What do you actually want, then? I’m asking for real, not trying to talk you into the backyard kickball thing.”

He thought about it for a long time, long enough that I almost filled the silence myself, but I made myself wait him out.

“I don’t know. I guess I just wanted to tell someone it’s annoying. I don’t need you to fix the picking thing. I just wanted you to know it happened.” He paused. “And maybe, I don’t know, maybe you could just play catch with me after dinner sometimes. Not even kickball stuff. Just regular catch. Like we used to before you got busy with work again.”

That one hit different than I expected it to. I’d been so locked into solving the recess problem – the social dynamics, the team captains, the whole external machinery of it – that I’d missed the much simpler thing sitting right next to me on the floor, which was that he just wanted some uncomplicated time with me, nothing to fix, nothing to prove, just the two of us and a ball in the backyard with no stakes attached to it at all.

“Yeah,” I said. “I can do that. Tonight, even, if you want, before it gets dark.”

“Okay.” He finally stood up, started untying his shoes properly like a normal human being instead of a sad lump in the entryway. “Can Mom make the chicken thing tonight though, I’m starving.”

Just like that, apparently, we were done talking about Marcus and Caleb and kickball captains, at least for now. We played catch for maybe twenty minutes after dinner, nothing fancy, just back and forth in the yard while the sky went that end-of-day orange, and he didn’t bring up recess again and neither did I. At one point he overthrew it into the hedge on purpose, laughing, clearly more interested in making me chase it down than in actually playing catch correctly, and I let him have that too.

I found out a couple weeks later, almost by accident, that Marcus had started coming over to Caleb’s house a lot because their moms had become friends, carpooling to some after-school thing, and it genuinely had nothing to do with Sam at all, just logistics and schedules bumping two kids together more than usual. I told Sam, thinking it might help, and he just shrugged and said “huh, okay” and went back to his Legos, like it barely mattered anymore, which maybe it didn’t, not in the way it had that day on the entryway floor.

We still play catch most nights it isn’t raining. I never did teach him the kickball thing. He never asked again either.

One evening a couple weeks in, mid-throw, he asked me, out of nowhere, if I ever got picked last when I was his age. I told him the truth, that yes, plenty of times, and that I still remembered exactly which gym it happened in. He nodded slowly, like that was useful information to file away somewhere, and then threw the ball a little harder than usual, grinning, like he’d just won something small and private that had nothing to do with recess at all.

When your kid comes to you upset, how do you know whether they want you to fix it, or just want you to sit on the floor with them for a minute?

More Like This